Pumpkin pie for reals!

Oct 11, 2013 | Featured, New, Recipes | 2 comments

Warning! This is not some holistic nutritionist’s attempt at making pumpkin pie healthy by substituting the fat for apple sauce and the sugar for stevia; this is the real deal!  This is a rare treat in my house, but oh-so-savoured! Enjoy!

This recipe is adapted from the Joy of Cooking (I know it’s sacrilege to adapt anything from this book, but I’ll take my chances). The recipe said this would make one 9-inch pie. I doubled it, though and got three out of it. 

Cook your pumpkin by washing it, cutting it in half, cleaning out the seeds and strings, and placing face-down on a cookie sheet with a bit of water to steam it.  Bake at 350º for about 20 minutes or until the flesh is soft when pierced with a fork.  Let it cool slightly, then scrape out the pulp and put into a food processor or blender.  Process until smooth.  Be careful: this is where I can’t stop eating warm pumpkin straight out of the processor!  I have learned to make extra!

 For a printable version click here.


Enough pie dough to line one 9-inch pie plate (this recipe is also from the Joy of Cooking; again I doubled everything and got three pies)

2 c. cooked pumpkin (yes you can use canned, but don’t – just call me for a pumpkin)

1½ c. evaporated milk or rich cream

¼ c. brown sugar

½ c. white sugar

½ tsp. salt

1½ tsp. cinnamon

¾ tsp. ginger

½ tsp. nutmeg or allspice (allspice is so great here, it adds a slight bit of peppery after taste that is yum)

¼ tsp. cloves

2 eggs, slightly beaten

Mix all the ingredients and pour into pie shells.  Bake 15 minutes at 425º, then reduce heat to 350º and bake about 45 min. longer or until an inserted knife comes out clean.  Serve with whipping cream. 

I served this at our Thanksgiving dinner last year and it was met with moans!

Don’t feel guilty…this is a wholesome treat.  Enjoy and bless every bite!

Remember to celebrate and be thankful for all the greatness and love in your life.  Happy Thanksgiving!


Empowering you to create your vibrant life!


  1. Pam

    My fav! Making this recipe tonight! Happy Thanksgiving!!

    • Sue

      You too Pam! We made ours tonight and they were delish!


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More from the blog

Two exercises (and a drink) to support your liver

Two exercises (and a drink) to support your liver

As May draws near, can you feel the energetic shift in the atmosphere? Those of us in the Northern hemisphere point our faces in the direction of the sun as we step outside. We pause. We smile as we feel warmth and light bathe our skin. As we unbutton our coats and...

Gifts of Gratitude: A 31-Day Challenge!

Gifts of Gratitude: A 31-Day Challenge!

My Seventh Annual Gifts of Gratitude starts Dec.1! Will you be joining me? I know you have experienced many challenges over the past couple of years. I have too, in fact I am recovering from Covid as I write this from my bed. What an interesting time we're in! It's...

Screenshot of Sue Crites Qi Gong at Home Breathing Techniques

Craving the peace of a quiet mind?

Learn a simple Energy Breathing technique to instantly calm your body & quiet your thoughts.

Sign up now to get the free training video & PDF guide delivered straight to your inbox today:

Enjoy Five Minutes of Qigong With Me Now and Experience Peace and Harmony! 

Sign up to access the FREE Video!

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest